Kanye West: BULLY (Album Review): Full Breakdown
Hi everyone, it’s Anthony Stirford here from Anthony XO.Music, and today I’m finally talking about BULLY, the new record from Kanye West.
Look, at this point, we don’t need to recap the resume. Kanye didn’t just join the club. He built the damn house. He’s the reason rap moved away from the tough-guy tropes and into soul samples, raw vulnerability, and personal mess. From the chipmunk soul era to the cold, industrial chaos of Yeezus, he’s been the blueprint for basically everything you hear on the charts right now.
But let’s be real. That “visionary” tag is getting harder to defend. The last few years haven’t just been unstable, they’ve been exhausting. After the sprawling, messy heights of Donda, we got the Vultures era with Ty Dolla $ign. And honestly? Those projects felt like watching someone throw paint at a wall and forget to check if any of it actually stuck. Loose, unpredictable, and feeling more like content than actual albums.
The road to Bully has been even uglier. Standard delays and leaks, sure, but the AI discourse was the real breaking point for a lot of people. When fans started hearing what sounded like AI-generated vocals in the early tracks, the backlash was loud enough to actually force a response. He promised a human record with no AI involvement. So here we are.
The pressure on Bully isn’t really about whether Kanye can still make a classic. It’s more fundamental than that. We’re asking whether there’s still a pilot in the cockpit. Whether he still has a real grip on his own art, or if we’re just watching the wheels finally come off.
Before getting into the album itself, we have to talk about how we even got here, because Kanye’s career arc isn’t just unusual. It’s a fever dream.
Back in the early 2000s, hip-hop had a gatekept identity. Lyrical titans like Nas and Eminem. The untouchable production of Dr. Dre. The blueprint was set in stone. Then Kanye showed up and just ignored it. With The College Dropout and Late Registration, he wasn’t just breaking through. He was hijacking the culture entirely. He traded the street-tough persona for soul samples and emotional transparency. He made it okay for rappers to be vulnerable, and in doing that, he shifted the entire axis of mainstream music.
But he got bored. In the late 2000s, he pivoted into cold, alien territory. When 808s & Heartbreak dropped, people were genuinely confused. When Yeezus arrived, people were pissed. It was abrasive, distorted, and intentionally uncomfortable. Critics called it weird or a mess. Fast forward a decade and that exact DNA is everywhere. You don’t get the high-voltage rage rap of Playboi Carti or the melodic angst of Lil Uzi Vert without Kanye kicking that door down first. He made the ugly sound cool.
By the mid-2010s though, the cracks started showing. The Life of Pablo wasn’t just an album. It was a living, breathing disaster zone of constant updates and shifting tracklists. Maximalism at its most frantic. Then you had Ye, minimal and stripped back but deeply inconsistent. That’s where Kanye stopped being a brand of quality and started being a brand of unpredictability. You never knew if you were getting a finished masterpiece or a rough draft.
In the 2020s, that unpredictability spiraled into something close to total chaos. Donda was massive, beautiful, and completely bloated with ideas. Then the Vultures era happened, and suddenly we were looking at projects that felt unfinished. Lazy, even. Flashes of the old genius buried under piles of unpolished rubble.
So looking at Bully, the question isn’t whether Kanye can reinvent himself. He’s done that a dozen times already. The real, high-stakes question is whether he can still finish a thought. Whether he can take all that scattered brilliance and actually build something again, or if we’re just looking at more debris.
Yeah… finally. The GOAT is back. And this time it actually feels like he knows what he’s doing again.
Compared to the chaos of Vultures and even parts of Donda, this is a completely different approach. He’s not chasing mess anymore. He’s not hiding behind distortion just for the sake of it. This feels like a genuine reset. You can hear the DNA of 808s & Heartbreak and My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy all over this thing, but it’s not nostalgia. It’s more like he’s pulling from those eras to stabilize himself after years of being completely all over the place.
This album came in messy too. Delays, backlash, people calling him out for AI vocals. That whole conversation was loud. But listening to this, I don’t hear AI. I hear samples. A lot of them. And honestly, that’s still where Kanye wins. He knows how to build atmosphere out of fragments. The spoken word interludes, the outros, all of that adds real texture. And hearing Asha Bhosle show up here? That caught me completely off guard. I don’t even know how he got there, but it works in that strange, only-Kanye kind of way.
Production is way cleaner than Vultures. Not safe, but controlled. The distortion is still there, especially in the first half, but it doesn’t feel like it’s suffocating the music anymore. Bringing in Andre Troutman was a smart move. His presence is all over the album, especially on “FATHER” and “ALL THE LOVE.” You can feel that bounce, that groove, something that’s been genuinely missing for a while. And having James Blake touch the final track adds that cold, electronic atmosphere Kanye has always used at his absolute best.
Lyrically, Kanye is still sharp when he actually wants to be. His verses? Still hit. Still sound like someone who knows exactly how to cut through a beat. But some of these hooks are genuinely frustrating. Like really frustrating. They feel lazy. Repetitive in a bad way. Not hypnotic, not catchy, just underwritten. That contrast hurts because the verses deserve so much better.
Vocally though, this is one of his better performances in years. You can hear both sides of him. The emotional, stripped-back delivery from 808s and the bigger, more commanding presence from MBDTF. He switches between them naturally, and that balance carries a lot of the album on its own.
“KING” comes in loud and direct. No buildup, no slow intro. Just energy. Kanye sounds locked in and focused, like he actually wants to prove something again. It sets the tone exactly how it should.
“FATHER” with Travis Scott is easily one of the best moments here. Not just because it’s a big collab, but because it actually works. The chemistry is real. The production starts off smooth, almost jazzy, then flips into something way more aggressive when Kanye steps in. Then Travis comes in and just takes complete control of the track like he owns it. He keeps the momentum going instead of killing it. That’s genuinely rare for a Kanye feature these days. This one feels alive.
“HIGHS AND LOWS” slows things down but doesn’t lose any weight. It leans fully into that 808s emotional space. Heavy, a bit distant, almost cold. It sits right in the middle of the album and gives it some breathing room without ever dragging it down.
“ALL THE LOVE” might have the best production on the whole project. That robotic sadness from 808s is back. The way it opens feels almost alien, then it transitions into those heavy synth layers Kanye built his entire career on. There’s even this slight Arabic vocal texture running through it that adds something completely unexpected. It sounds massive. But again, the hook doesn’t hit as hard as it should. That’s a recurring problem that keeps showing up at the worst times.
The title track “BULLY” should have been one of the biggest moments on the album. And parts of it genuinely are. Kanye sounds vulnerable, reflective, almost fully exposed. Then the hook comes in and just ruins all of that momentum. It’s repetitive in the worst possible way. It doesn’t build anything, doesn’t evolve. It just sits there looping:
“Yeah, obey, hey
Baby, do what I say
Like it ain’t no other way
Baby, do what I say…”
That’s not hypnotic. That’s lazy. It’s easily the weakest chorus on the entire album. And it’s frustrating because the rest of the track actually had real potential.
Then you hit the middle section of the album, and this is where things start slipping hard.
“MAMA’S FAVORITE,” “LAST BREATH,” “THIS IS A MUST,” “PUNCH DRUNK,” “WHITE LINES,” “PREACHER MAN,” “THIS ONE HERE.” None of these are bad. And that’s actually the problem. They’re not bad, they’re just unfinished. They feel like ideas that should’ve been pushed so much further. Hooks that needed another pass. Verses that needed more bite. Production that needed one more layer before anyone hit export.
It honestly feels like Kanye got halfway there and just stopped. Like he had the full blueprint for great songs and didn’t bother completing them. That’s what makes this stretch genuinely frustrating. You keep waiting for something to explode, and it never does.
“CIRCLES” with Don Toliver is where things actually fall apart. This isn’t mid. This is bad. It’s short, empty, and honestly just confusing. When it played, I had that immediate “what the hell is this?” reaction. For a Kanye and Don Toliver collab, this is embarrassing. No chemistry, no energy, nothing to hold onto at all.
“DAMN” isn’t as bad, but it doesn’t need to exist. It feels like filler. Kanye sounds completely disengaged, like he recorded it just to fill space. On an album that already struggles with focus, this does not help.
The frustrating part is how strong the beginning is compared to everything that follows it. The first few tracks feel intentional, sharp, even genuinely exciting. Then everything slows down, loses direction, and starts blending together into this shapeless middle section that the album never fully recovers from.
And that’s really what holds BULLY back.
Because this could’ve been great. You can hear the ambition. You can hear the reset. You can hear him actively trying to reconnect with what made his best work actually hit. And in moments, it works. The highs are real highs.
But the middle of the album kills the momentum completely. Too many tracks feel incomplete. Too many hooks feel underwritten. It ends up sounding scattered instead of focused, and that’s a gap that’s hard to ignore when the opening stretch sets the bar that high.
Still, this is way more promising than anything he’s put out recently. It’s not the chaotic mess of Vultures. It’s not as unfocused as the worst parts of Donda. It’s a real step back toward control, toward actual intention.
He didn’t fully land it. Not even close to his peak.
But for the first time in a while, it actually feels like he’s trying to get back there.
Rating: 6/10 (It’s a “Gym Rotation Approved” to me)
- Favorite Tracks: FATHER, KING, ALL THE LOVE, SISTERS AND BROTHERS, HIGHS AND LOWS
- Least Favorite Tracks: CIRCLES, DAMN
Listen On Spotify:
If you liked this review, you can check out my other reviews: